Modarabas — A performance review
Investors should not ignore the scrips offering attractive PER
Jan 01 - 14, 2001
For a considerably long time investors have been ignoring Modarabas. There is a general perception that investing in modaraba certificates is not attractive. While the perception may be close to reality, there are certain good performing modarabas which offer earnings yield which is much higher than the return from savings deposits and even Defence Saving Certificates.
According to a report from Khadim Ali Shah Bukhari & Co., prepared by Nadeem Naqvi, a brief study of ten selected modarabas exhibits some interesting observations. These ten modarabas, out of a total of over 50, were selected on the basis of profit after tax of Rs 25 million or above posted for the year ending June 30, 2000.
These ten modarabas posted a 6.5 per cent increase in total income for the year 2000 amounting to Rs 2.55 billion as against Rs 2.39 billion the year before. Gross Profit (defined as total income less funding and lease amortization cost) rose by 7.4 per cent, although the gross margin remained constant around 32 per cent. Similarly, operating profit (gross profit less administration cost and modaraba company fee) rose by 4 per cent, while operating margin slipped slightly to 27.4 per cent from 27.9 per cent during this period.
The important difference between the year 2000 and 1999 came under the provisioning head. For the year 1999, these ten modarabas made a combined provision of Rs 146 million, while in 2000 they made a provision of Rs 41 million — a decline of 72 per cent. Mainly, as a result of this, the Profit after tax for this group shot up by 26.6 per cent in 2000 to Rs 630 million from that of Rs 497 million for the year 1999. The net margin improved to 24.8 per cent from 20.8 per cent for the year 1999.
More interesting from an investor's perspective is the fact that the payout by these ten modarabas increased from Rs 381 million for the year 1999 to Rs 483 million for the year 2000 — an increase by 27 per cent. Further, the consolidated dividend yield (prices as of January 1, 2001) for this group rose to 25.1 per cent for the year 2000 compared to 19.8 per cent for the previous year — not bad at all considering that the KSE-100 Index showed a return of only 7 per cent for the year 1999.
Total certificate holders' equity rose by 3.7 per cent to Rs 3.5 billion, while total assets grew by 3.7 per cent to Rs 7.4 billion. For the year 2000, the ROE for these ten modarabas was 17.5 per cent compared to 14.5 per cent for the previous year. The ROA came out at 8.5 per cent versus 7 per cent respectively for the two periods.
Based on an average share price for the group (as of January 1, 2001) of Rs 7.10 and book value per share of Rs 13.17, the average price to book ratio is 0.54x, which is an attractive value considering the very high dividend yield. The historic PER for the group is 3.1x compared to the historic market PER of 9.5x for the KSE-100 Index for the year 2000. This translates into a massive earnings yield of over 32 per cent compared to 8 to 10 per cent yield an investor can expect from savings deposits and 14 per cent on Defence Saving Certificates.